Stick, balm or cream: which format?
A solid deodorant comes in three forms: the stick, which you glide under your arm, the balm in a jar, which you scoop with a finger, and the cream. The formula matters more than the format, but the format changes your daily routine.
| Format | What it has going for it | What it asks of you |
|---|---|---|
| Stick | Goes on without your fingers, can't leak, fits in cabin luggage | A little skin warmth in winter to glide well |
| Balm in a jar | Easy to dose, melting texture | Applied with a finger, a jar to open and close |
| Cream | Absorbs quickly | Applied with a finger, often contains more water and so preservatives |
I chose the stick because it's the closest thing to a regular deodorant: cap off, two or three strokes, done. No fingers, no jar left on the edge of the sink.
With or without baking soda?
Baking soda neutralises odour well, but it is very alkaline. On the thin skin of the underarms, especially after shaving, it is the first cause of redness and stinging with natural deodorants.
Other actives do the same job more gently: magnesium hydroxide or oxide, triethyl citrate, zinc ricinoleate. In the INCI list, look for SODIUM BICARBONATE: if it comes first and your skin is reactive, skip it. I explain it all in my article on baking soda-free deodorant.
Unscented or scented: which one?
Fragrance and essential oils bring allergens, which the INCI list names at the end: GERANIOL, LINALOOL, LIMONENE... If your skin reacts easily, go unscented. If you like a light scent and your skin is fine with essential oils, a scented version will do nicely.
During pregnancy and breastfeeding, many women prefer to avoid essential oils. I've set out what to look for in my article on deodorant during pregnancy, and your midwife or doctor is still the right person to ask.

The same formula, with organic palmarosa essential oil for a light floral note. 50 g stick, at least 6 months.
How long does a solid deodorant last?
Depending on the brand, from 3 months to 6 months or more. It depends on the weight, the texture and how much you apply. And it is what sets the real price: a €10 stick that lasts 3 months costs more per month than a €14 stick that lasts 6.
How to apply a solid deodorant
- On clean, fully dry skin. Deodorant on damp skin doesn't hold as well.
- Two or three strokes are enough. More doesn't mean more effective, and it wears the stick down too fast.
- In winter, hold it against your skin for a second before gliding: cocoa butter melts with the warmth of your skin.
- Wait a few seconds before getting dressed. Used sparingly, it leaves no white marks.
- Keep it somewhere cool. Away from heat and humidity, not on a sunny windowsill.
If you've just shaved and your skin stings, wait a little before applying it, or use it in the evening.
The first few weeks: what to expect
A natural deodorant doesn't block sweat: it works on the bacteria that cause odour. If you're coming off an antiperspirant, you'll sweat again for the first few days. That's normal, and it usually settles within a few weeks.
Judge your new deodorant over two or three weeks, not on day one. The steps are in my article on baking soda-free deodorant, and if you're new to solid cosmetics, my beginner's guide will save you the usual mistakes.
To be complete: my deodorant has no organic label on the finished product (4 of its 6 ingredients are organic, Ecocert certified) and there's no refill yet. It comes in a plastic-free cardboard tube, made in France 40 km from my workshop.



